This first Brainwash compilation marks the beginning of an era, a move into territory that Brainwash have barely begun to tread, the emergence of a cultural peak in the land of Leeds, and so on, so why is it that I have given this compilation a measly 4? Well, a variety of reasons, the most subjective being “I didn’t like it” and the most objective statement coming in the form of, oh wait, I can’t be objective. Well, damn.
Joking aside, the criticism I am about to embark on is not intended as a blow to Brainwash as promoters, as I am assured they do a fantastic job bring a host of bands “up North” (it’s grim, don’t you know) as well as starting their own festival in October, which has attracted the likes of Ólafur Arnalds, Maybeshewill and Forward Russia. It seems Brainwash can’t really put a foot wrong, but well (and this is genuinely unwelcome news), their compilation is pretty poor.
All of the ingredients for it to be a success are there, it’s just that it has been so badly put together, that when playing it for the first time this compilation becomes a patchwork catastrophe, with split seams, dodgy craftsmanship and well, if it were a jacket, it would be a straight jacket.
Opening with a nice little “hello, welcome to the first Brainwash compilation, enjoy”, the listener is easily sucked into believing that their journey through this CD will be a smooth one and the use of Jonquil as compilation opener only adds more weight to this idea. For those who are not familiar with Jonquil (shame on you), they are a wonderful, Youthmovies-related outfit who have released one moderately successful album to date, entitled Lions. The title track of this record features on the Brainwash compilation and is an ever favourable sea shanty, about, erm, building houses in a certain way so lions can escape easier. Nonetheless, it’s a wonderful song and my only qualm with it is that it’s been condensed to a one minute edit, which seems rather pointless as the song only totals in at 1:57 on the album anyway. Looking back, this maltreatment of Jonquil should have rung alarm bells instantly, but on first listens I was far too naïve and well, hoping that this record might offer up something half-decent.
On we move though, at a blistering rate may I add, to Red Stars Parade, who I originally thought were quite pants, but this was before hearing Pulled Apart by Horses. Returning to Red Stars Parade, they are basically an unassuming bunch, who you know, give songs super-cool names like “Jack O’ Knives” and sound a bit like 30 Seconds to Mars. It’s hardly anything to get excited over, but Kerrang gave it four of their Kicking-ass Kings in a recent review, so if you dig Kerrang, chances are you will like this too.
So, we have had one good band, one not so good, then on swing Jetplane Landing with one of the most ridiculous songs, EVER. At least that’s what they want you to think, because, you know, it references Les Savy Fav and they are totally hip, and it has a load of stuff going on in it, and, and, and… is what you would be saying if you were some sort of brainwashed (get it?) monkey. Jetplane Landing’s “Why do they never play Les Savy Fav on the radio?” is a real waste of effort. Yes, it’s kooky, if that’s what you’re into, but if it were asking the genuine question “why do they never play Les Savy Fav on the radio?” surely there would be some mention of the fact that major radio stations are far too scared of change and Les Savy Fav do have a reputation for being a bit weird. No, there is no mention of that here, instead, this is, what I feel, a rough translation of the thought processes of Jetplane Landing:
1) Sound totally American
2) Fill the song with crazy breakdowns to show we can take a joke
3) Make sure it sounds ironic!!!
Well, ironic songs = ironic eye rolling. Please don’t bother with Jetplane Landing, it’s like giving in to a child that’s purposely attention seeking; the parent looks weakened in the eyes of the child and the kid knows it can try it again and probably get away with it. Super Nanny would agree. Oh, and did I mention that certain “vocals” in the song sound like Thurston Moore’s piss-take attempt at rapping on The Whitey Album? Exactly. Stand well clear and block your ears.
Wintermute offer some of the usual At The Drive-In styled sounds that you can hear on most “band nights” at your local pub, so it’s up to These Monsters to pull me out of the aural dirge that is this compilation so far; thankfully they do, and offer up 10 minutes of relaxing jazzy post-rock keeping thoughts of “change the cd, change the cd, change the cd” at bay.
At this point, things look like they are picking up; I have just experienced the soothing sounds of These Monsters and the next few artists on this record are pretty decent too. Paul Marshall offers up a sweet folk ballad in the style of Simon & Garfunkel and Random Number’s “Crosets” is a nice slice of electronica that is easy on the ears. Vessels show up next, and as they simply can’t put a foot wrong, their track “Clear and Calm” easily transports us onto Youthmovies’ excellent “Shh! You’ll Wake It”.
Then it all goes a bit wrong again. Pulled Apart by Horses turn up, with teen angst baggage and all and offer up the song “I Punched a Lion in the Throat”. Now this is a bad song, some might even say a musical travesty. It contains the lyrics “ultimate power/maximum life” which sounds like the slogan for Homer Simpson’s “Power Sauce”. Just like this apple based energy bar, the listener soon discovers that this song doesn’t really have any energy behind it, and rather than being made out of apple cores and old newspapers (like in The Simpsons episode), “I Punched a Lion in the Throat” is formed out of tired riffs and an uninspired band.
In short, some more songs happen, and then the compilation closes on a seventeen minute effort from Human Fly which features spoken-word artist Rose Kemp. While this song isn’t at all disagreeable, in fact it’s rather good, slapping it on right at the end is the final nail in the coffin for this album.
I haven’t really explained my overall disliking for Brainwash’s first compilation yet, so please allow me to do so now, just to justify myself to both fans of the compilation and Brainwash themselves. The promoters have obviously decided to cram everything in at once and alternate between genres just to show how much they have to offer. Honestly, they do have a plenty of great bands under their belt, but splicing them together in this order just spells catastrophe. Compilations like this were necessary when not everyone had easy access to the internet, or music, but with the Myspace phenomena, now anyone can listen to any band they like and form an opinion of them through the 4 to 5 songs available on their music page.
Similarly, if someone was interested in what Brainwash has to offer, they would no doubt sift through their top friends (who are mainly made up of the bands that are on this comp), give each band a listen and if they like what they hear, maybe buy a record or two. Fitting every single artist Brainwash has been involved with onto one compilation no longer works because music listeners expect things to be catered to them. If you can download an entire album by one great band, why should you have to listen to a compilation that hasn’t bothered to tailor itself to you?
While listening to an entire compilation and making notes on the bands you enjoyed and the ones you didn’t used to be merriment to us all, a certain new-breed listeners seem to no longer have the patience for this. Instead of shoving everything under one “compilation”, the artists on this record should have been split up onto different EP’s. Perhaps one for bands like Red Stars Parade, Pulled Apart by Horses and even Deus Volt, another EP for folks like Jonquil, Paul Marshall, We vs. Death, and so on. Yes, this would have required a lot more effort and I am certain some will see flaws in my thinking, but frankly, I don’t see why anyone should be forced to listen to bands they don’t enjoy just so a promoter can say “we have a full-length album out with so much stuff on it, it’s insane.” I agree, if Brainwash had of released separate EPs with rough genre guides, it wouldn’t open up other bands to listeners and may even come across as a bit closed minded, but it’s a sign of the times if scatty compilations are being released and consequently ignored by music fans who simply don’t have the time to sift through garbage to find the gems.
Apologies if the previous paragraphs come across as half-baked nonsense from a rambling music reviewer who doesn’t know what they are talking about, but I simply had to discuss (in my own little way) the redundant “qualities” of compilations like this. Now, Brainwash, please accept my apology and continue to put on fine gigs on up North.